Category: wildlife management

Nosy predators check out the competition

Growing up in New Zealand, I had a great passion for animals. Viewing everything through a child’s eyes, I believed that all wildlife should be free to thrive anywhere they wanted. Today I see the realities of the world were all animals are cherished, but some are out of place and others are vulnerable. I am not alone in realising the endangerment and damage that pest species can cause to our native species. This awareness has me seeking to understand the appropriateness of eliminating certain species from particular locations in order to protect others.

The flora and fauna within New Zealand are some of the most remarkable in the world. A large majority of the animals and plants (and fungi) are endemic, or unique, to New Zealand. Over the years, many species have been introduced to New Zealand, such as ferrets, stoats, hedgehogs and ship rats, that have put these unique animals and plants at risk. It has become vital that monitoring and control of these predators is implemented to allow our native species a greater chance of survival.

Research to improve strategies and techniques to monitor and remove these predator species has been underway for many years now. One method used to monitor these predators is through deploying food-based lures that attract the target animals to traps or cameras. This allows for observations to be made in order to determine the density of these species in the surrounding area, as well as to increase the chances of trapping and removing these animals.

One way to attract these predators is to use odours from more dominant predators to attract the target species to the traps or cameras. This technique is based on the observation that mammals, like stoats and rats, use scent as their primary sense to forage for food and detect dominant species (higher ranking species than themselves). Dominant species directly influence the behaviour of mesopredators (mid ranking predators) by either attracting them or repelling them away from the odour. A dominant predator’s odour may provoke the subordinate (lower ranking predator) into preforming eavesdropping behaviour. This behaviour is used by species to inspect the location where the dominant predator has roamed. If the location is good enough for the big, tough predator then maybe it is a good place for the subordinate as well.

Researchers from Lincoln University, University of Auckland and Landcare Research chose to test ferret odour verses fresh rabbit meat (a traditional lure) for stoats, hedgehogs and ship rats. This study took place at Toronui station, a 1500 hectare sheep and beef farm located in Northern Hawkes Bay. It lasted for 64 days trial.

From left to right; Stoat (Mustela erminea), Hedgehog (Erinaceus europaeus), Ship Rat (Rattus rattus) and Ferret (Mustela putorius furo), all mammalian predators introduced to New Zealand. Charlie Marshall, (CC BY 2.0), https://www.flickr.com/photos/100915417@N07/49407663736; Jesus Duarte, (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0), https://www.flickr.com/photos/26795194@N00/8897432606; Amanda and William Explore, (CC BY-NC 4.0), https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/120567285; Max Moreau, (CC BY 2.0), https://www.flickr.com/photos/9426349@N07/6085681724.

The results from this trial confirmed that the ferret odour was the best for attraction, at least for stoats and hedgehogs, while rats avoided the ferret odour. Other studies have also found that rats avoid fresh odours. Stoats showed the strongest attraction to the ferret odour, with double the number of stoats being observed at the monitoring stations compared to fresh rabbit meat. These results can lead to exciting new possibilities to improve the monitoring and management of these species, especially in places where they are predicted to be rare.

One surprising result that was found was that the population of stoats at Toronui station before the study began was estimated to be rare. After the study was completed, the stoat population was predicted to be widespread. This makes you wonder just how underestimated the population of stoats in New Zealand really is.

Studies like this are important as New Zealand. With very limited native mammals, the native species, such as birds and insects, within New Zealand have had no need to adapt to mammalian predators. As a consequence when predator mammals were introduced into New Zealand they caused devastating damage to the endemic species.

Ferret odour lures were found to last longer than the fresh rabbit meat lures. This means that the ferret odour lures can be left out in the field for a longer period of time and still work just as well. Rabbit meat lures become ineffective faster leading to underestimates of pest populations.

The finding of the effectiveness of ferret odour as an attractant, especially in stoats, introduces a new tool and opportunity for pest management and conservation. It opens up many paths for future research to develop and learn more about this type of monitoring and the positive effects that it could have on our native species. More recent work has reported similar outcomes.

Mammalian predators are a major threat to the unique biodiversity that we have in New Zealand. New discoveries, such as the use of dominant predator odour in predator removal, gives me hope that there is a future for our taonga, native species.

The author Stacey Lewthwaite is a postgraduate student in the Master of International Nature Conservation taught at Lincoln University. This article was written as an assessment for ECOL 608 Research Methods in Ecology.

Garvey, P. M., Glen, A. S., Clout, M. N., Wyse, S. V., Nichols, M., & Pech, R. P. (2017). Exploiting interspecific olfactory communication to monitor predators. Ecological Applications, 27(2), 389-402.

August 18, 2022
The spitfire: a sure-fire way to eradicate stoats?

Stoat! Look out, the RAF (Really Awesome Field-research) is coming! Photo CC BY-NC 2.0 Stuart Smith, Flickr

Stoats, weasels and ferrets: the terrifying trio. If New Zealand’s native birds could speak, I’m sure that’s how they would refer to them as they swap stories of escape and near misses. Widespread, wily and lethal, the stoat is considered the greatest threat to the survival of many endangered and threatened native birds on the mainland, such as the takahe, orange-fronted parakeet, and Leonardo DiCaprio’s favourite, the kakī (black stilt).

Here are the cold, hard facts. Humans introduced stoats from Europe to control rabbits in the 1880’s, against the advice of ecologists at the time. They have since run rampant over our native bird species, throwing many populations into a drastic decline. Like clever little kleptomaniacs, they sleep on beds of feathers stolen from our most treasured and rare birds.

We must eradicate stoats from areas of New Zealand if we are to have an extant bird as our national icon. The prevailing question is, how?

Photo CC BY-NC-ND 2.0 Shellie Evans, Flickr

Never fear, the Spitfire is here! Unless you are a stoat then, yes, be afraid. The Spitfire is a re-setting toxin delivery device which was trialled in the Blue Mountains of Otago in 2013. 65 Spitfire devices were set up for approximately six weeks. Each device was capable of delivering 100 lethal doses of the stoat killing toxin PAPP (para-aminopropiophenone).

The stoat population was monitored in the area during this time using trail cameras and tracking tunnels in order to measure the Spitfire’s effects.

The project was carried out by Elaine Murphy, Tim Sjoberg and James Ross from Lincoln University, along with researchers from Wildlands, the Department of Conservation and Connovation. They found that the Spitfire knocked down 62% of the stoat population in the trial area.

The Spitfire is a very picky individual, only delivering the lethal dose of poison to a suitor of the right body size and shape. The device is able to do this due to its dual sensors. Cameras trained on the Spitfire devices during the trial in Otago recorded no instances of non-target species, such as rifleman, receiving any of the poison. PAPP has been registered for use in stoat control since 2011, but is mostly available for use in fresh meat lures, which are labour intensive to produce and expire quickly.

The 2013 trial was a success for the Spitfire and PAPP, but it was not without it’s issues. It was a trial after all! Many of the devices malfunctioned before the end of the six week trial due to design faults in weather proofing and circuitry. The conclusion was that the Spitfire showed promise, but lacked in stamina and sturdiness.

Kereru in Kawakawa, Photo CC BY 2.0 Geoff McKay, Flickr

All was not lost! In 2016 the New Zealand Government announced its goal to become predator (rats, mustelids and possums) free by 2050, which led to a funding initiative called ‘Products to Purchase‘ from PF2050 Ltd. Five products were selected, based on their expected contribution to the cause, to receive funding to fast track their development to a marketable level.

In 2019, the first five successful applicants were named, and who should be among them but our voracious Spitfire. A Tauranga based start-up called Envico Technologies Ltd (ECT) went back to the drawing board with the device. They re-engineered and re-invigorated the design and produced a prototype they could now commercialise, all with the help of the funding from PF2050 Ltd.

The Spitfire was back in the game, with the new design finalised in 2020. The latest model promises a longer lifespan of one year, during which no maintenance or refills are required. It’s widely known that the main cost in stoat control is in the field hours with bait station and trap operations, so this hands-free option is looking like an economical as well as an effective choice.

Also on the toolbelt of the new Spitfire model is a bluetooth data logger, which records the date and time of trigger events. ECT envisions this feature being highly beneficial for monitoring pest populations and assisting with re-invasion events in eradicated areas. Because of it’s long field life, the Spitfire becomes an attractive option for use in more remote areas where previously the only viable option has been aerial 1080 drops. If you have a ‘Ban 1080’ bumper sticker, this product may be for you.

Brushtail possum and her joey at Tārerekautuku Yarrs Lagoon, Photo Katherine Turton.

Just when you think it can’t get any better, a distinct advantage of the Spitfire is that there are few issues with alternative food sources or bait shyness. Stoats don’t have to bite, pull, stand on a treadle, or count backwards from 100 to receive a lethal dose. They are simply drawn in by an automatic lure dispenser that keeps a delicious mayonnaise paste coming all year-round.

The Spitfire is an intellectual. It has smart capacitive sensors that can detect and measure anything that is conductive. It can tell the difference between the long sausage body of a stoat and a little compact rifleman, preventing our inquisitive native species from receiving the toxin. When the Spitfire senses a stoat it launches a lethal splurge of toxin onto the abdomen, after which the animals are instinctually driven to groom off the mess.

ECT joined forces with the Department of Conservation and Boffa Miskell to conduct field trials from 2020-2022. Alongside the stoat design, a model specifically for our Australian foes, the brushtail possum, was also trialled using a Diphacinone and Cholicalciferol toxin instead of PAPP.

Field trials are about to conclude for the Spitfire and ECT are expecting to roll out the finished product at $200 a piece. There is also talk that a rat specific Spitfire is now in the works! This innovative technology is paving the way for more effective pest control not just here in New Zealand but worldwide. Conservation groups get your wallets ready and watch this space!

For more information, see the article on the Sptifire trial in Otago and follow ECT to keep up with their latest technological solutions for conservation!

This article was prepared by postgraduate student Katherine Turton as part of the ECOL 608 Research Methods in Ecology course in her Master of Pest Management degree.

August 1, 2022
Is your house cat a ‘super-predator’?

A bell on a collar is commonly used by cat owners to try to protect local wildlife. Or at least to avoid dead carcasses being presented inside the home. A study of domestic cat behaviour at the Ōruapaeroa/Travis Wetland, Christchurch, suggests that this approach may not be as effective as you might expect.

Collar-bell warning devices are likely to be largely ineffective at reducing hunting success. This conclusion was drawn after a 12-month study of 88 domestic cats living close to the 119 ha wetland reserve. This is consistent with most (but not all) similar New Zealand and overseas studies. An explanation for such a confounding outcome may be due to a cat’s tenacity and ability to easily learn to compensate for the bell. Couple this also with the likelihood that birds don’t necessarily associate a bell warning with danger.

Photo credit: CC BY-SA 2.0 Brandon O’Connor, Flickr

Cat night curfew, another wildlife protection strategy required of responsible owners in Australia and promoted in New Zealand, may even be counterproductive. Many of our native species of birds and reptiles are mostly active during daylight. They hunker down and hide during night hours.

Mice and rats prefer the evening for their foraging explorations. These rodents are invasive pests that do immeasurable damage to New Zealand natives species, including birds. Since cats, by cultural convention and scientific study, are known to prey on rodents, it might seem detrimental to lock them inside at night.

Travis Wetland, is the last large freshwater wetland in Christchurch and is home to 53 species of birds. It has an estimated diversity of 700-900 invertebrate (mainly insect) species, many endemic to New Zealand. The urban cat research project at the wetland site was conducted by masters student Shelley Morgan, from Lincoln University. The study concluded that house cats in urban settings, bordering sensitive nature reserves like Travis Wetlands, do roam and incorporate these wildlands into their home ranges. There they target mostly rodent pests, but sometimes more precious native animals, like lizards and birds. Cats with bells were not any less effective in bringing home prey!

On balance, you might think that domestic cats provide beneficial services to bird populations by controlling mice and rats. This view is widely debated, with some recent studies arguing that cat predation has an overwhelming negative impact on native wildlife especially in wetlands, braided rivers and along shorelines. Furthermore, it seems likely that just a few of the moggies are particularly troublesome. Some cats are ’super-predators’, exhibiting a high tendency towards hunting, often focusing on a favoured prey. It appears that this little clowder of cats may have a disproportionate impact on threatened native species. As confronting as these uncomfortable facts are, they need to be acknowledged and solutions sought.

Photo credit: CC BY-SA 2.0 Niels Hartvig, Flickr

New Zealand has one of the highest levels of cat ownership in the world, with over half of households supporting at least a single cat. The social benefit of pet ownership, and the passion that we hold for our cats, should not be underestimated. A social licence to restrict ownership or cat movements will be difficult to achieve. Nevertheless, almost certainly within the community of cat lovers will be a myriad of ideas for limiting the danger to treasured native species.

One option is to seek agreement for a suitably sized cat-free buffer zone between urban and nature reserves. Although a risk remains that the absence of domestic cats in a halo around a wetland reserve might just encourage remaining cats in the district to prowl further and expand their hunting range.

The Royal New Zealand Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA NZ) classifies cats into companion, stray and feral types in a recently published white paper. The organisation acknowledges the impact of free roaming cats on native biodiversity, but stresses the need to protect cat welfare and manage them humanely. The RSPCS promotes the need for cat owner self reflection, community debate and appropriate council bylaws. In the meantime, if you suspect that your beloved companion is a ‘super-predator’, perhaps consider a ‘Birdsbesafe‘ collar cover. Unlike a bell, the ‘birdsbesafe’ collar offers a colourful warning of a cat’s presence and alerts prey with good colour vision (birds and lizards).

Morgan, S. A., Hansen, C. M., Ross, J. G., Hickling, G. J., Ogilvie, S. C., & Paterson, A. M. (2009). Urban cat (Felis catus) movement and predation activity associated with a wetland reserve in New Zealand. Wildlife Research, 36(7), 574-580. https://doi.org/10.1071/WR09023

This article was prepared by postgraduate student Andrew Wells as part of the ECOL 608 Research Methods in Ecology course in his Master of Pest Management degree.

July 25, 2022
Seduced by the Stoat Stench

As a child who was raised next to the ocean, I suppose it’s only fitting that the beach is my attractant. Something about the sand between my toes takes me back to when I was 6. My talents were at a peak as I managed to take the win in multiple sandcastle competitions. The sea gives me a sense of security and allows my mind to reset, clearing all worrying thoughts. And of course, it is the foundation behind most of my hobbies; fishing, diving, swimming (and sandcastle building). The beach has always been a part of my upbringing, a place where I enjoy the company of family and friends.

Beach Day – CC BY-NC-ND Image by Anna Meban

One of the things I found most interesting after a trip down to the beach was how my little jack russell paid far more interest in me when I returned home. Now maybe this had something to do with us neglecting to take him with us, but he would always sidle up to me, frantically sniffing and then stare at me longingly, as though I had betrayed him. He knew I’d made friends with a passing puppy on the beach and he knew that whoever had left these hairs entwined in my clothing was not him.

It’s important to remember that these attractants differ, especially when they include scents such as urine, scats and bedding odours. Yes, you read that right, these are the types of odours that Lincoln University’s Elaine Murphy and James Ross, along with their fellow colleagues, investigated in terms of the power of attraction in stoats (Mustela erminea). More specifically their study discussed whether body odours of reproductively fertile (oestrous) stoats have the potential to be used as lures for pest trapping.

Their study, published in the journal Animals, tested these lures in a series of lab and field trials. Lab trials were undertaken at Lincoln University and involved wild-caught stoats. The experiment was set out in a way where each odour sample was placed in a metal mesh tea ball, allowing stoats to smell but not interact. As well as this, a control sample was used, consisting of unscented Dacron, allowing stoats to choose between scented and unscented chambers.

The field trials differed slightly, with the lure stations providing a menu selection of stoat odours and more traditional lures consisting of hens eggs and dried rabbit meat. The field trials took place in a range of New Zealand’s well-known locations, Abel Tasman, Lake Rotoiti (Tasman) and the Coromandel.

Exploratory Stoat – CC BY 2.0 Charlie Marshall (Flickr)

This got me thinking about how important scents are as an attraction method for animals, even for humans themselves. It may be the scent of home-cooked meals in the kitchen. The strong scent of cologne as your crush walks by. The smell of salty air drawing me to the ocean and reminding me of home. Everyone has something they are attracted to but these things differ depending on the person… or species.

In Abel Tasman and Lake Rotoiti, the trials compared fertile female stoat bedding odours to a dried rabbit meat block formulation. In the Lake Rotoiti trials, they also tested a combination of both lures together. It was the Coromandel trial that grabbed my attention, as this focused on whether male odours had the same charm as females. The trial was divided into two stages, first the male stoat bedding odour was partnered with either dried rabbit or hen eggs, and second, the male bedding odour was trialled on its own.

The lab and field trials both showed very promising outcomes for the control of stoats. In the captive animal trials, stoats had greater interaction times with stoat odours than with the control dacron. Stoat odours were just as much preferred by stoats as the hen eggs and dried rabbit meat. Male odours were also equally effective attractants for both males and females showing interest in the scent of the opposite sex.

So what can we do with these alluring aromas?

Well, it is becoming increasingly more evident that food lures in the wild are not always the most effective way of targeting stoats when using kill traps and bait stations. Although these are the best techniques at the moment, conservation workers still struggle to catch stoats in many locations. Elaine and her colleagues mention how this is likely due to every individual having different preferences (basically a personality), as well as stoats being spoilt for choice in terms of food sources in certain areas.

With all pest control there will be some animals that manage to dodge the bullet. The use of odour as a lure adds another technique into the mix. This new tool may be just what we need to increase chances of stoat capture rates in areas where food is abundant.

Stinky Stoat – CC BY-SA 2.0 Airwolfhound (Flickr)

What’s even better is that, as stoat populations begin to decline, this scent lures method will only become more effective! As desperation sets in and survivors scramble to find mating opportunities, they will lead themselves right into their own funky smelling fate.

But wait, there’s more…

From the results gathered within this study, it is thought that these stinky stoat odours may have even more potential than just capturing stoats. In conjunction with traditional lures, these odours also captured the attention of ferrets and rats. With the looming deadline of ‘Predator free 2050‘, this research could be the next step in trying to reduce these sneaky (and stinky!) pests.

More research is now needed to figure out which chemicals are driving the attraction and how to produce these lures in a form that can be utilised nationwide, Elaine, James and their colleagues are on the trail of a breakthrough scent that has the potential to revolutionise predator trapping methods. Something to think about next time I’m at the beach.

The author Anna Meban is a postgraduate student in the Master of Science – Conservation and Ecology taught at Lincoln University. This article was written for an assessment for ECOL 608 Research Methods in Ecology.

April 18, 2022