Imagine walking through the lush forests of New Zealand, where native birds sing and the ecosystem thrives. For many, the thrill of hunting deer adds to the adventure, as these animals are both prized game and an integral part of the environment. However, lurking within this paradise are predators, like possums and rats, which threaten the very fabric of this delicate ecosystem.
To combat these problem predators, New Zealand has employed a controversial yet effective method: aerial 1080 poison drops. These toxins are effective against pests but can inadvertently harm other wildlife, including the beloved white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus).
Brad Smith. July 3rd 2006
White-tailed deer are not native to New Zealand; they were introduced for hunting in the early 20th century. Despite being an introduced species, they have established a stable population and have become an important part of New Zealand’s hunting culture, especially the population on Stewart Island. Protecting them is crucial not only for maintaining biodiversity but also for supporting the recreational and economic benefits associated with deer hunting.
Recent studies have shed light on how we can minimise this collateral damage by using deer repellents. Let’s dive into the findings and their implications for both wildlife management and conservation.
New Zealand’s unique biodiversity is under constant threat from invasive species. Possums, rats, and stoats prey on native birds, insects, and plants, disrupting natural ecosystems. To protect these vulnerable species, aerial drops of sodium fluoroacetate, commonly known as 1080, are used. This toxin is highly effective at reducing predator populations, but it’s not without its drawbacks. One significant concern is the unintended by-kill of non-target species, such as the white-tailed deer.
Intensive ground-based searches for white-tailed deer carcasses were conducted in the Dart Valley/Routeburn catchments following the aerial application of 1080 cereal pellets as part of the ‘Battle for the Birds’/Tiakina Ngā Manu predator control program in August 2014. Lincoln University PhD student Kaylyn Pinney, with her supervisors James Ross and Adrian Paterson, organised this search. Four areas, each 100 hectares in size, were searched over four days. The results were published in NZ Journal of Zoology.
To estimate the effectiveness of their search, simulated deer carcasses were used. The success rate for finding these simulated carcasses was 78%. All actual white-tailed deer carcasses found contained traces of 1080 in their muscle tissue (ranging from 0.41 to 1.06 mg/kg). Based on these findings, researchers estimated that approximately 3.85 deer per 400 hectares died from 1080 poisoning. This translates to a potential mortality of about 146 white-tailed deer across the entire 15,215-hectare predator control area. These results suggest that recurrent predator control operations could impact the sustainability of white-tailed deer hunting. (For more on this see ‘Is it fair, for orcs and deer?’)
Repellents are substances designed to deter animals from consuming certain items without causing them harm. In the context of predator control, deer repellents can be coated on 1080 baits to reduce the likelihood of deer ingesting the poison.
Kaylyn Pinney then tested a deer repellent-coated 1080 bait to see if it could reduce the mortality of white-tailed deer during predator control operations. She tested two types of repellents: Epro Deer Repellent (EDR) and Pestex-DR. The study was divided into two parts: trials in a captive herd on the West Coast and monitoring of wild deer fitted with GPS collars in the Dart/Routeburn Valley in Otago, New Zealand.
yiwenjiang26, Routeburn vally closer up. March 10 2007.
In the captive trials, five deer were presented with three types of cereal baits: non-repellent (NR), EDR-coated, and Pestex-DR-coated. The baits were placed in a controlled environment where deer could freely choose among them. The results were promising. The deer showed a clear aversion to the repellent-coated baits, with significantly less consumption compared to the non-repellent baits. The repellents appeared to be effective, though not infallible. One older buck did consume a single EDR-coated bait initially but avoided it afterward.
The second part of the study involved monitoring ten wild deer equipped with GPS collars during a 1080 drop. To fit the deer with GPS collars, Kaylyn and crew captured the animals by tranquilising them and then attached the devices. Kaylyn could now track their movements and monitor their survival. The results were mixed. One deer, the youngest in the study, died from 1080 poisoning, suggesting that body size may play a role in susceptibility to the poison. Importantly, the study confirmed, however, that using EDR significantly reduced deer mortality compared to previous operations without repellents.
While the study shows that repellents can reduce by-kill, there are challenges. Ensuring that every bait is adequately coated with repellent is crucial. Additionally, different deer may react differently to repellents, as observed with the older buck in the captive trial. Kaylyn suggests that using a lower concentration of 1080, such as 0.08%, could further reduce deer mortality, especially for smaller deer.
The study also highlights the importance of understanding deer habitat use. The GPS collars allowed researchers to identify how much time the deer spent in different types of habitats. The varied exposure of the collared deer to the 1080 baits was influenced by their movement patterns and habitat preferences. Future studies should consider these factors to optimise bait distribution and minimize non-target impacts.
Shaddon Waldie, 1080. July 30th 2009.
These findings have significant implications for wildlife management and conservation in New Zealand. By using deer repellents like EDR and Pestex-DR, we can make predator control operations more targeted and reduce the unintended consequences for non-target species. This approach not only helps protect the native ecosystem but also addresses public concerns about the humane treatment of wildlife.
The study underscores the need for continuous innovation and adaptation in conservation strategies. As we gain more insights into the behaviour and ecology of both target and non-target species, we can develop more effective and sustainable methods to preserve New Zealand’s unique biodiversity.
The journey to protect New Zealand’s native species is complex and challenging. This study offers a glimmer of hope by demonstrating that deer repellents can significantly reduce the by-kill of white-tailed deer during aerial 1080 operations. While not perfect, these findings pave the way for more refined and humane conservation practices. As we continue to balance the needs of predator control with the protection of non-target wildlife, studies like this guide us toward a more sustainable and harmonious coexistence with nature.
Imagine once again walking through those lush forests, now knowing that both the native birds and the majestic deer can thrive in a balanced ecosystem.
This article was prepared by Master of Science postgraduate student Ella Gordon as part of the ECOL608 Research Methods in Ecology course.
Link to the main article
Pinney, K. A., Ross, J. G., & Paterson, A. M. (2022). Assessing EDR and a novel deer repellent for reducing by-kill of white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus), during aerial 1080 operations. New Zealand Journal of Zoology, 49(3), 199–214. https://doi.org/10.1080/03014223.2021.1978510
Additional Links and Further Reading
New Zealand Department of Conservation
The New Zealand Department of Conservation (DOC) website provides comprehensive information about New Zealand’s natural heritage, conservation efforts, and recreational opportunities. Key sections include:
Parks & Recreation: Information on places to visit, activities, camping, and hiking.
Nature: Details on native plants and animals, pest management, and habitats.
Get Involved: Volunteering, funding opportunities, and educational resources.
Our Work: Conservation projects, research, and monitoring programs.
- Link to website
https://www.doc.govt.nz
Manaaki Whenua – Landcare Research
The Manaaki Whenua – Landcare Research website provides a wide range of information on New Zealand’s land environment and biodiversity. It covers research areas such as soil health, water management, biodiversity conservation, and climate change. Additionally, it offers resources for educators, data and mapping tools, and information on various conservation projects. The site also features sections for news, events, and opportunities for public involvement in environmental efforts.
- Link to website
https://www.landcareresearch.co.nz
1080: An Overview
The “1080: An Overview” page on the Predator Free NZ Trust website provides comprehensive information about the use of 1080 (sodium fluoroacetate) in New Zealand for predator control. It details what 1080 is, why it is used, its application methods, and its effectiveness. The page also covers the benefits and risks associated with 1080, including its impact on native species, non-target species, and the environment. Additionally, it includes examples of successful 1080 applications and addresses common concerns such as its impact on drinking water.
- Link to website
https://predatorfreenz.org/toolkits/trapping-baiting-toolkit/bush-large-areas/1080-an-overview/
Nugent, G., & Yockney, I. (2004). “Feral deer in New Zealand: current status and potential management.” New Zealand Journal of Zoology.
This article discusses the status and management of feral deer populations in New Zealand.
Morriss, G. (2007). “Epro Deer Repellent reduces by-kill of deer during aerial 1080 operations.” Landcare Research Report.
This report provides detailed findings on the effectiveness of EDR in reducing non-target by-kill.
Frampton, C. M., et al. (1999). “Efficacy of 1080 carrot baits in controlling possums.” New Zealand Journal of Ecology.
This study examines the effectiveness of 1080 in controlling possum populations.
Spalinger, D. E., et al. (1997). “Influence of learning and experience on foraging behavior of white-tailed deer.” Journal of Wildlife Management.
This research explores how learning and experience affect deer foraging behavior.
Bowen, L. H., et al. (1995). “Leaching rates of 1080 from RS5 cereal baits under simulated rainfall.” New Zealand Journal of Ecology.
This paper discusses how environmental conditions affect the concentration of 1080 in baits.
Pinney, M., et al. (2020). “Effectiveness of deer repellents in reducing non-target by-kill during predator control operations.” Journal of Wildlife Management.
This study delves into the specific effects of deer repellents on non-target species during 1080 operations.
Leave a Reply