Southern accent, penguin descent

There is a great song by Tom Petty which I always find moving. ‘Southern Accents‘ conveys the longing to be back home with kith and kin when you are living away from them. This is summed up by the line ‘There’s a southern accent, where I come from‘.

Having grown up on a sheep farm in South Otago (just out of Balclutha and a few kms from Telford) I can certainly claim that there is a southern accent where I come from. I still have plenty of kin down there and when I take the family down to Kaka Point for the Christmas holidays, the ‘rolling r’ is very much in evidence.

Often the students that I teach also have this accent and I can usually even tell if they are from South Otago or Eastern Southland (although I couldn’t explain the difference).

A truly great song and a great album from Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers.

Having lived away from Clutha for 28 years, first in Dunedin and then Canterbury, I have almost lost my ‘rolling r’ (although, interestingly, my sons developed the accent for a while when they learned to talk).

Sometimes it pops out though. It doesn’t help that my parents moved to a farm just out of Ashburrrton, which I end up saying a lot. So, this accent is a little clue to my past. It tells a listener that I am likely from the southern part of New Zealand.

Why does the accent exist? It’s not the result of genetic mutation and yet it is passed from one generation to the next. If a child is born in Balclutha or Gore, or points in between, then the predominant accent they hear is that of the locals and so the accent is passed from one generation to the next. No genes required, just a similar environment for each generation.

There is speculation that the accent is a remnant from the predominantly Scottish settlers in the region. So behaviour can tell us something about the past. How far back can it provide information for?

The Nuggets from the Deep South. There are lots of rolling r’s to be heard here. Image from Adrian Paterson.

In biology we are often interested in how species and their traits have evolved. We use all sorts of information to help reconstruct what ancestors were like, where they lived, and what they did. Genes and morphology (what traits look like) are commonly used.

What about behaviour? Can behaviour tell us about what happened in the evolutionary past (hundreds to thousands of generations ago)? There are some obvious arguments against using behaviour like this: instability (behaviours can change from use to use), evanescence (behaviour only lasts a short time and are gone), lack of trait independence (behaviours don’t really have clear beginnings or endings but rather merge into one another), small likelihood of fossilisation (no way to actually know for sure what ancestors did) and problems with homology (how do we know that a behaviour that we see in one species is really the same as one that we see in another species).

These are all good questions that have been asked since Darwin wrote the first book on animal behaviour. Over the last couple of decades various researchers have looked at what behaviour can tell us about evolution of species, usually with positive results.

For example, as part of my PhD I looked at this question in New Zealand seabirds, like albatrosses and shearwaters. In recent years I have asked similar questions about penguins. Penguins are a great charismatic bunch of birds, a widely distributed group of species spread around the Southern Hemisphere. As Joe Bennett said this week (in The Press) “Penguins are barely birds. Their feathers are like fur and their wings are flippers. They swim like seals, they walk like drunks and the fly like bricks”.

Yellow-eyed penguin. Image from Adrian Paterson.

While we know which bird species clearly belong to the penguins, the relationships among the penguin species and how they are related to other bird groups is much less clear. This is likely because penguins are so adapted to the marine environment that it has removed many morphological clues. There are only so many ways that you can look if you spend all day swimming about.

Perhaps behaviour will fare better and provide information about penguin history? My colleagues Russell Gray (formally University of Auckland), Graham Wallis, Martyn Kennedy (University of Otago) and I set about finding out.

In research published in Cladistics, we were able to show that it’s a complex answer. We worked under the principle that similar behaviours found in some species implied that they were closely related (the behaviour has evolved in a common ancestor and been passed on).

We started by collecting information on behaviours, such as courtship and aggressive displays, and life history traits, such as types of nests and timing of breeding. The main difference between these types of traits was that behaviours were clear actions performed by the penguins whereas life history traits were the outcomes of behaviour decisions. For example, living in forest is not a behaviour but it is the consequence of behavioural decisions made by individual penguins.

We collected 68 traits that we could compare between penguin species. We then took this data and constructed an evolutionary tree for the penguins. A good reasonably sensible tree was made from the data but how could we tell if it was the ‘correct’ tree?

Yellow-eyed penguins interacting after returning from foraging. Image from Adrian Paterson.

For penguins there has been extensive DNA analyses of their evolutionary relationships over the last few years and we are reasonably confident that we have the ‘correct’ penguin tree based on DNA. It was then a matter of comparing our behavioural tree with the molecular tree. Surprisingly, the trees did not match significantly.

Why is this surprising? Well, most other studies like this on other animal groups have found that behaviour trees are just as accurate as molecular trees. So what is up with penguin behaviour? Were penguin behaviours more changeable than other types of animals?

Mapping behavioural traits onto the DNA trees indicated that many of the traits had persisted for millions to tens of millions of years. What seemed to have happened, though, was that some behaviours in different penguin species were similar to one another, not because they had inherited the behaviour from a common ancestor, but because they had converged to be similar looking behaviours with similar functions (penguin species essentially look the same – swimming rugby balls with a pointy end – and do the same things – bother fish and nest and relax on land).

Perhaps this is because the selection pressure of living in a marine environment constrains the kinds of behaviours that will mahi there. Perhaps the morphological changes of penguins adapting to water constrain the types of behaviour that these body shapes can perform.

So, while some penguin behaviours tell us about the distant past others tell us about the compromises that penguins have made to living in an environment reasonably foreign to most other birds.

This is a little analogous to my southern accent. The ‘rolling r’ of southern NZ tells us that ancestors of the current population came from Scotland (which mine did). However, some of my friends at school had parents that had emigrated from the Netherlands after the war. They still had the southern accent but that was an adaptation to living in the southern environment where everyone else had the trait.

As Tom Petty sings “I got my own way of talkin’, but everything is done, With a southern accent, where I come from“. Our work, both in this paper and in the future, focuses on how to tell the difference between these kinds of behavioural similarities for penguins and people.

This EcoLincNZ article was written by Adrian Paterson in 2013. In upgrading to a new site it was lost. I am uploading and lightly editing some of these old articles to let new readers access them. Much of my research over the last 13 years has continued to be behaviourally focussed but mostly on animal movements, especially braided river bird species, and not much on evolution of behaviour (which is a shame).

Comments

Leave a Reply